Unpaid dues, late fees, and liens

Unpaid assessments are how HOAs keep the lights on. They are also how a late fee becomes a recorded lien and, in the worst files, a foreclosure. That path is real. It is also slower, more noticed, and more state-regulated than a lot of hallway talk suggests. Nolo's encyclopedia puts it plainly: if you fall behind, the association can typically charge late fees, record or rely on a lien, and in more serious cases foreclose — but state law may set a minimum debt or a minimum time, and the CC&Rs still have to authorize the steps.

This page is the usual sequence: late fee → demand → lien → foreclosure. It is not a reason to stop paying. It is a map so you can see which step you are actually on.

The pay-under-protest theme

If you dispute a fine, a charge, or even the amount of an assessment, the practical move in many files is still to keep the regular assessment current while you dispute the rest in writing. Why: several states let associations lien and foreclose for unpaid assessments, but restrict foreclosure for fines alone. California Civil Code § 5725(b) says a disciplinary fine may not be treated as a foreclosable assessment. Texas Property Code § 209.009 bars foreclosure of a lien that consists solely of fines. Florida Statute § 720.305 says a fine of less than $1,000 may not become a lien.

Payment-application statutes matter here. Texas § 209.0063 generally applies a payment first to delinquent assessments, then current assessments, then collection attorney fees tied to assessments, then other attorney fees, then fines. Arizona § 33-1807(K) also puts unpaid assessments first unless the member directs otherwise. Florida § 720.3085(3)(b) is the other way: accepted payments go first to interest, then late fee, then collection costs and attorney fees, then the delinquent assessment — and a restrictive endorsement on the check does not change that. So "pay under protest" is not one magic phrase. It is: know how your state applies money, keep the lienable charges current if you can, and put the dispute in a separate dated letter.

Do not withhold all dues because you are mad at the board. That is how a $75 fight becomes a foreclosure file. See the dispute-options page for internal appeal, ombudsman, small claims, and lawyers.

Typical path

1. Due date, then late. Your documents say when the installment is due. Arizona § 33-1803 treats a payment as late if unpaid 15 or more days after the due date unless the documents give you longer, and caps late charges at the greater of $15 or 10% of the unpaid assessment, only after notice that it is overdue. Florida § 720.3085: interest from the due date at the rate in the declaration or bylaws (not above the legal maximum; if silent, 18% simple — not compound), plus an administrative late fee not exceeding the greater of $25 or 5% of the installment if the documents allow it.

2. Late-assessment notice / opportunity to pay without attorney fees. Florida § 720.3085(3)(d) says the association may not require attorney fees on a past-due assessment without first delivering a written notice of late assessment that specifies the amount and gives 30 days to pay without those fees. That notice is a statutory form.

3. Collection / demand, sometimes a 30- or 45-day clock. Arizona § 33-1807(L): at least 30 days before authorizing an attorney or outside collection agency, certified-mail notice that the account will be turned over, in bold or all caps, with contact information to discuss payment. Texas § 209.0064: before you can be liable for a collection agent's fees, certified-mail notice that lists each delinquent amount, describes payment-plan options if they apply, and gives at least 45 days to cure. Texas associations with more than 14 lots must offer a payment-plan policy (§ 209.0062) with a minimum term of three months.

4. Pre-lien notice. California Civil Code § 5660: at least 30 days before recording a lien, certified-mail notice with an itemized statement, collection-procedure summary, records-inspection rights, a bold warning that the property may be sold without court action, and your rights to a board meeting, internal dispute resolution, and ADR before foreclosure. Florida § 720.3085(4): no recorded claim of lien unless a written demand gives 45 days after mailing to pay, in a statutory form, sent by registered or certified mail and first-class mail.

5. The lien. Some states treat the declaration itself as recorded notice of a continuing lien (Arizona § 33-1807(F): recording the declaration perfects the common-expense lien; further recordation is not required). Others want a claim of lien in the public records before foreclosure (Florida). Texas § 209.0094: before filing an assessment lien, two delinquency notices — first by first-class mail or email, second by certified mail not earlier than the 30th day after the first — and the association may not file the lien before the 90th day after the second notice.

6. Foreclosure — only after more notice, and often only for assessments above a floor. California § 5720: generally no judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure if delinquent assessments (excluding late charges, collection costs, attorney fees, and interest) are under $1,800 and not more than 12 months delinquent. The association may still small-claims or record a lien that it cannot yet foreclose. California § 5705: before initiating foreclosure the association must offer IDR or ADR (owner's choice, except binding arbitration is off the table if the association intends judicial foreclosure); the board itself, not the manager, must vote in executive session at least 30 days before any public sale. Texas § 209.0092 generally requires a court order (expedited foreclosure or a judicial foreclosure) rather than a purely private sale. Arizona § 33-1807(A): the association may foreclose a common-expense lien only if the owner has been and remains delinquent for 18 months or $10,000 or more, whichever occurs first, and the board must use reasonable efforts to communicate and offer a reasonable payment plan first. Member expenses (as opposed to common-expense assessments) are not enforceable as that foreclosure lien. Florida foreclosure of an assessment lien is a judicial mortgage-style action, and § 720.3085(5) adds another 45-day intent-to-foreclose notice after the lien is recorded.

Nolo's foreclosure overview: an HOA lien usually attaches when assessments are due, when the CC&Rs were recorded, or when a notice of lien is recorded; the association may then foreclose as the CC&Rs and state law allow, even if the mortgage is current.

Typical timeline (typical / check your docs and state)

| Step | Typical range | Labeled examples | |---|---|---| | Assessment due, then late | 10–15 days after due date | AZ: 15 days unless docs are longer | | Late-assessment notice (no attorney fees yet) | 15–30 days after due | FL: 30 days to pay without attorney fees | | Collection / attorney turn-over notice | 30–45 days | AZ: 30 days. TX collection-agent fees: 45 days | | Pre-lien demand | 30–45 days | CA: 30 days certified. FL: 45 days | | Lien recorded / claimed | After the pre-lien window | TX: not before 90 days after the second delinquency notice | | Foreclosure decision / filing | Months, not days | CA: assessments ≥ $1,800 or > 12 months delinquent; board vote 30 days before sale. AZ: 18 months or $10,000 | | Redemption after HOA sale (if any) | Statutory, not universal | Texas § 209.011: generally 180 days after the association mails notice of the sale |

What to check in your documents

If a lien is already recorded, get a written payoff that separates assessments, late fees, interest, attorney fees, and fines. Dispute the line items you dispute. Pay the lienable assessments if you can. Talk to a licensed lawyer in your state before a foreclosure sale date — that is past DIY.

This is general information from an AI helper, not legal advice. Confirm it against your documents and your state's law. If a deadline or hearing is coming up, talk to a licensed lawyer.

Related

Not a law firm. Not legal advice. Confirm this against your documents and your state’s law.